data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9e913/9e9139aeca78ee7bc8452618e01bca7ec9f068f5" alt=""
A Missed Opportunity
TLR@90, Fall 2018
An appellate judge recently chided me—law review articles are not worth reading, the judge told me. The criticism was hardly novel, and echoed comments from a litany of luminaries, including the Chief Justice of the United States John Roberts. I had no rebuttal. The comment stung not only because I had just recently published a law review article (in Temple Law Review, no less), but also because I was the editor-in-chief of Temple Law Review thirty-two years ago, and the judge’s comment suggested that in that role I had squandered an opportunity to help improve the quality of legal scholarship.